New ICE billboards on Charlotte interstates warn of dangerous immigration violators

Updated: Nov. 9, 2020 at 2:48 PM EST
Email This Link
Share on Pinterest
Share on LinkedIn

CHARLOTTE, N.C. (The Charlotte Observer) - Billboards are popping up along interstates in Charlotte with photos of local criminal suspects and offenders wanted by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

The federal agency announced the billboard campaign in a news release Friday night, in which ICE blames local “sanctuary policies” for the men’s release.

“Too often sanctuary policies limiting cooperation with ICE result in significant public safety concerns because they release dangerous individuals back into the community we are attempting to protect,” ICE official Tony Pham said in the release.

ICE called the local suspects and offenders “at-large” and “dangerous.”

The billboards are on Interstate 85 just north of Billy Graham Parkway, on I-77 near Arrowood Road, on I-485 near Dixie River Road and Nations Ford Road, and on I-277 near Hamilton Street.


The campaign appears to involve a more than two-year-long feud between ICE and Mecklenburg County Sheriff Garry McFadden, although ICE did not name the sheriff in its billboard campaign.

Last year, a senior ICE official blasted what he called McFadden’s “dangerous and reckless” policy of allowing undocumented immigrants charged with crimes to walk out of jail with no call to ICE, The Charlotte Observer previously reported.

McFadden fired back at the time, saying he follows state law on the release of inmates. He criticized ICE for not inviting him to sit down and discuss the situation and said he was being used as a “political pawn” for federal officials' failure to solve the nation’s immigration problem.

McFadden sent this statement to The Charlotte Observer:

"I remain deeply disappointed in the tactics that ICE employs, not to mention the misinformation regarding the role of the Sheriff which ICE puts out to the public in an effort to undermine my authority while overstating my responsibility.  I do not employ “sanctuary policies” as ICE’s website suggests.  Rather, I employ PUBLIC SAFETY policies that I believe are in the best interest of everyone in Mecklenburg County based upon my decades of experience in law enforcement.  I do not release individuals from custody as ICE’s billboards suggest.  Rather, when a Judge or Magistrate ORDERS that an individual SHALL BE RELEASED upon fulfilling certain terms and conditions including payment of a bond, I abide by that Court Order as I am REQUIRED to do so by law and by my oath of office.  I am not required to honor ICE’s detainer requests nor will I – for reasons that I have stated repeatedly now for several years:  I do not believe it is in the best interest of the community for the local Sheriff to do ICE’s job for them.  I believe it is important for local law enforcement to have a more productive, cooperative and trustworthy relationship with everyone who lives in Mecklenburg County, so that victims of and witnesses to crime can feel encouraged to come forward without fear of repercussion including the potential of deportation.

"ICE labels the individuals on their billboards as public safety threats, based primarily if not exclusively upon recent charges which have yet to be proven in a court of law.  One individual is charged with second degree rape and violating a domestic violence protective order. Those are very, very serious charges. Shouldn’t he be brought to justice?  Shouldn’t he be allowed to confront his accusers?  Shouldn’t his victims have their day in court?  Shouldn’t our criminal justice system be allowed to show the community that it works?  ICE doesn’t think so.  Rather, ICE would just deport this defendant as soon as he makes bond – sweeping him under the rug (or back to his home country).  Where is the justice for those victims? Where is the deterrent value to that defendant or others who might consider such crimes but who are here illegally? What does it say to those individuals when the only ramification for being charged with a serious felony is a free ticket home?  Another individual featured on ICE’s billboards appears to have been convicted of illegally entering the United States in 2012.  If that’s the case, ICE should be able to prosecute him for the federal felony of illegally RE-entering the United States – a charge that would bring with it a Criminal Arrest Warrant and no bond, requiring that he be held in custody presumably until he is deported again.  Ask ICE why they don’t bring illegal re-entry charges when they can.  I have.  They say they’re too busy, that it’s too much work, or that the U.S. Attorney’s Office cannot process those charges quickly enough.  These individuals are so dangerous that ICE feels compelled to put them on billboards because of the public threat ICE says they pose, yet ICE can’t figure out how to get obvious charges on them that would hold them in custody?  And then they point Uncle Sam’s finger at me for not exercising my discretion and doing their job for them?  Isn’t that more than a little hypocritical?  Or disingenuous?

“I am hopeful that last week’s elections will soon bring much needed reform to our immigration system, and that ICE will receive more thoughtful directives from their new leadership. Meanwhile, I will continue to act in what I believe to be the best interest of everyone who lives in Mecklenburg County.”


President Donald Trump weighed in on the dispute last year. He retweeted a tweet by the conservative foundation Judicial Watch that said: “Weeks after JW reported that the sheriff of North Carolina’s biggest county released numerous violent illegal immigrant criminals from custody, new federal stats reveal that the problem is statewide.”

“That, and many other reasons, is why Republicans will win North Carolina!” Trump tweeted.

Men featured on the billboards include:

▪ 26-year-old Paul Chander Evans, arrested by Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police on charges including assault on a female and felony breaking and entering.

▪ 29-year-old Andres Bautista-Alcantara, arrested on charges of second-degree forcible rape and violating a domestic violence protective order.

▪ 25-year-old Omar Palomo-Garcia, arrested and charged by CMPD officers with assault on a female and felony cocaine possession.

Copyright 2020 The Charlotte Observer. All rights reserved.