Cover Story: Judging the judges - | WBTV Charlotte

Cover Story: Judging the judges

CHARLOTTE, NC (WBTV) - Campaign 2010.  Trial and error? 

Election Day is Judgement Day for local candidates for the bench.  The people vote.  But a lot of people say the way we decide is a miscarriage of justice.

The process by which we elect judges is simple. Perhaps too simple.  Practically one step away from drawing a name out of a hat.

One example, 13 candidates are in the running to become a judge on the North Carolina Court of Appeals - the second highest court in the state.

Even the most knowledgeable voter only has the slightest insight into who's qualified to sit on the bench.

And now a new twist.  In the Court of Appeals race voters statewide aren't just choosing one candidate. They have to pick their top three for the seat in a first-ever instant runoff.

They're calling it the "fruit basket" election.

But it highlights a larger problem.  On Tuesday's ballot, at least in Mecklenburg county, there are as many names to consider for judicial offices as there are for the other elected offices - like for Congress and county commission.

Is this any way to elect someone so important?

PrimeTime's Jeff Atkinson reports in our Cover Story.

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • No students injured in south Charlotte school bus crash

    No students injured in south Charlotte school bus crash

    Thursday, March 23 2017 8:18 AM EDT2017-03-23 12:18:19 GMT
    (Credit: CharMeck)(Credit: CharMeck)

    The wreck happened around 7:23 a.m. on Park Road near Sharon Road, shutting down all lanes in the area.

    More >>

    The wreck happened around 7:23 a.m. on Park Road near Sharon Road, shutting down all lanes in the area.

    More >>
  • Tractor-trailer crash slows traffic on I-77 NB near I-85

    Tractor-trailer crash slows traffic on I-77 NB near I-85

    Thursday, March 23 2017 7:16 AM EDT2017-03-23 11:16:58 GMT
    (Mark Davenport | WBTV)(Mark Davenport | WBTV)

    The wreck happened just before 6 a.m. on I-77 northbound just past the I-85 interchange. 

    More >>

    The wreck happened just before 6 a.m. on I-77 northbound just past the I-85 interchange. 

    More >>
  • Rowan-Salisbury Schools releases details on technology recognition

    Rowan-Salisbury Schools releases details on technology recognition

    Thursday, March 23 2017 7:01 AM EDT2017-03-23 11:01:56 GMT
    Source: Rowan-Salisbury SchoolsSource: Rowan-Salisbury Schools
    Additional details have now been released for the Rowan-Salisbury Schools as the school board and district are ranked among the Top 10 Nationally as a leader in the uses of technology for student success. The award announcement was made earlier this week, but now school officials are breaking down exactly what was recognized, and what they say it means for the district. Now in the 13th year, the top-ranked school districts were announced through the annual ‘Digital School...More >>
    Additional details have now been released for the Rowan-Salisbury Schools as the school board and district are ranked among the Top 10 Nationally as a leader in the uses of technology for student success. The award announcement was made earlier this week, but now school officials are breaking down exactly what was recognized, and what they say it means for the district. Now in the 13th year, the top-ranked school districts were announced through the annual ‘Digital School...More >>
Powered by Frankly